Behind Health Insurance Plan Rankings

The National Committee for Quality Assurance and U.S. News have worked together to create a ranked listing of various healthcare plans. As with anything these days, cost plays a major part in deciding on which healthcare plan you’ll likely go with. The hard part is being able to get a level of quality healthcare at an affordable price.

The list of rankings is available here, and it lists such criteria as customer service and ability to treat and prevent illness. A plan’s ability to diligently screen for cervical cancer using a Pap test was one of the 49 measures that each commercial healthcare plan needed to pass, with 39 measures needed to judge personal Medicaid plans.

Medicare plans were judged according to a list of 49 measures. One of the measures tested was how readily a caregiver handed out antibiotics for such ailments as the common cold. The withholding of antibiotics in these instances is a common practice that helps to contribute to the proliferation of drug-resistant viruses in our society.

Please enter a Zip code

Determining the Right Health Insurance Plan

You should consider whether or not a healthcare plan is right for your family based on some personal criteria as well. For instance, if you have infants or young children a healthcare plan that doesn’t work hard to keep immunizations current may not be the best cost-effective plan for your family. Likewise, if you have members of your family with diabetes conditions, a healthcare plan that doesn’t have a list of diabetes health programs may not be the best choice for your family.

It all boils down to balancing the necessary services being offered to your family against the costs associated with receiving those services. The 469 healthcare plans ranked in the survey, earned scores between zero and 100 with overall rankings of 1-5 stars. As with any ranking list, the results are merely for comparison with the final choice as to the ‘best healthcare plan’ being made by you.

Best Health Insurance Plans

Ranking Health Insurance Plan Plan Type U.S. News Score
1
Harvard Pilgrim Health Care
Massachusetts, Maine
HMO/POS
91.2
2
Tufts Associated Health Maintenance Organization
Massachusetts, New Hampshier, Rhode Island
HMO/POS
91.2
3
Harvard Pilgrim Health Care of New England
New Hampshire
HMO/POS
90.6
4
Grand Valley Health Plan
Michigan
HMO
89.1
5
Geisinger Health Plan
Pennsylvania
HMO/POS
88.2
6
Health New England
Connecticutt, Massachusetts
HMO/POS
88.1
7
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield – Connecticut
HMO/POS
87.8
8
Group Health Cooperative of South Central Wisconsin
HMO
87.8
9
Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Massachusetts
HMO/POS
87.8
10
CIGNA HealthCare of New Hampshire
HMO/POS
87.6

About the Author

Michelle